« Back to Main Blog

Scarcity or abundance?

IMG_1946I recently returned from Guyana where I spent my J-term cross cultural experience (a required part of my theological education). My time there with the people of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in Guyana truly was transformational. Now that may seem a bit like a cliché, for so often people go overseas and recognize that there are struggles and obstacles that the people in these places experience unlike what we face here in the United States. My experience with the people in Guyana showed me something completely different than what I was expecting.

There are plenty of challenges in Guyana—there is no potable water source other than expensive bottled water, their city infrastructure is tenuous at best and poverty is everywhere. To my American eyes, I saw tragedy all around me… hardly the place where I would expect hope and faith to flourish. The people of Guyana surprised me and taught me about how, even in the absence of what we as Americans take for granted, valuable ministry can and does happen.

It was a living example of the difference between a theology of scarcity and a theology of abundance. Walter Brueggeman, a world-renowned Old Testament scholar and a prophetic voice in our time, says that a theology of scarcity says there’s not enough food, water, housing, etc., so hold oIMG_2056nto what you have, hoarding it if you must. A theology of abundance, on the other hands, says you always have “enough” so it’s easy to give some of it away.

Partnering with the people of these local parishes in Guyana has transformed my expectations of what can be accomplished with few resources. Their sheer determination not to be defined by their limited circumstances is an inspiration for the true meaning of service and outreach.

I met with the president of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in Guyana. He said that the annual income for the churchwide organization there is around 5 million Guyanese dollars. The U.S. equivalent would be $25,000 per year. This comes from offerings from a total of only 48 churches, many of which are small rural congregations with only 20 active members and their children. Most of those members live on less than $200 U.S. dollars per month. Can you imagine? And with that money, they support Sunday school curricula, feeding programs for needy children and the homeless, as well as provide leadership training for lay people and potential candidates for public ministry.

It made me wonder who has the greater measure? Who is truly living out the Gospel in their everyday lives?

So, perhaps being a global church means that we don’t have all the answers when it comes to faith and service… perhaps we here in the United States need the lesson in abundance from those who seemingly have so very little.

Jennifer Michael is president of Women of the ELCA for the 2011-2014 triennium. She currently lives in Dubuque, Iowa where she is attending Wartburg Seminary.

+++++

Jenny provided the photos used here. The featured image from our home page is of a Sunday School student at Calvary Lutheran Church in Georgetown, Guyana. The top right photo with this post features the local unit of Church Women United in Georgetown. Jenny is pictured, above left, with Jocelyn, the vice president of the Evangelical Lutheran Church Women of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in Guyana.

Comments (3)
avatar
Myrna Wells-Ulland says:
Jan 30, 2014

I’ve often felt that many of our congregations suffer from the theology of scarcity. Christ came to give us life abundantly. Can we just live that theology? Thanks, Jenny. You go, girl!

avatar
Jennifer Michael says:
Jan 30, 2014

Thank you Myrna… you are so very right. When I saw the hope and ministry in Guyana, even from a community that had seemingly so very little… and then I compared that to a large, financially solvent church in the US that decides to reduce their own giving to their synod or to the churchwide organization… well, it isn’t hard to understand who is living out the Gospel and trusting in God fully.

It is such a simple lesson… but still we need to hear it.

avatar
Tom Coleman says:
Feb 04, 2014

Great article on scarcity vs. abundance

Scarcity vs. abundance—some estimated numbers to think about

The ELCA World Hunger Appeal raises about $20 million/year.

LWR spends perhaps $40 million/year.

Thrivent for Lutherans manages about $70 billion of financial assets for about 3 million Lutherans.

If, the return on average were 4%, then annual income for these Lutherans in aggregate would be $2.8 billion.

10% of $2.8 billion is $280 million.

1% of $2.8 billion is $28 million.

Get an image next to your comment by visiting Gravatar.com and uploading a profile photo that links to your email address.

Leave a Comment

All fields required unless otherwise noted.


We will never share or sell your email address.
(optional)